Saraki's Appeal Dismissed by Supreme Court. CCT Trial Continues

Date: 2016-02-05

The Supreme Court has dismissed Senate President, Senator Bukola Saraki's, appeal for lacking merit.

In a unanimous decision the Supreme Court has dismissed Senator Bukola Saraki's appeal. All five issues were resolved against Senator Saraki.

In the lead judgment taken by Justice Walter Samuel Onnoghen, the court held that the CCT was properly constituted to exercise jurisdiction over Saraki’s trial. It also resolved the issue of whether the tribunal had jurisdiction to try criminal matters and issue bench warrants against Saraki.

“I find no merit in the appeal, it is hereby dismissed,” the court ruled. The apex court had scheduled February 5 for judgment in the appeal of the senate president against the CCT. ‬ ‪

In November 2015, Mahmud Mohammed, chief justice of Nigeria, who led a panel of seven judges, announced the date after hearing the brief of the counsel to the plaintiff and the respondent. ‬‪ Making his argument, Joseph Daodu, Saraki’s lawyer, pegged his brief on three points. He argued that the CCT, in its trial of the senate president, was not properly constituted, and that the tribunal was not a court of competent criminal jurisdiction. ‬

“The CCT is just a disciplinary panel for public officers,” he had said. ‬ ‪He also argued that the case against his client was not properly initiated owing to the absence of an attorney-general at the time. ‬ ‪But Rotimi Jacobs, counsel to the CCT, urged the apex court to dismiss Saraki’s appeal for lack of merit. ‪He argued that tribunal was properly constituted, as only two members were required to form a quorum to sit in judgment on a case. He further argued that in the absence of the attorney-general of the federation, an officer in his office could initiate criminal proceedings against anyone as was in the case against the senate president. ‬

On November 12, 2015, the supreme court asked the CCT to stay proceedings in the trial of Saraki, pending the determination of the appeal before it. ‪In October 2015, Saraki approached the appeal court, asking it to quash his trial at the CCT. His request was also grounded in the argument that the CCT was not properly constituted, and that the tribunal lacked the power to try criminal matters.‎‎ ‪‎But on October 30, 2015, the appeal court dismissed Saraki’s argument that the CCT was not a court of competent jurisdiction to handle the criminal charges preferred against him. ‬

‪“The CCT is a court of criminal jurisdiction, albeit limited jurisdiction,” the court had held. ‬

‬‪“The immediate question is whether it is a court or not. There is no inherent difference between a court and a tribunal. The only difference is that tribunals in most cases handle special cases. The tribunal has power to impose sanctions according to the law. It is a court with specific criminal jurisdiction.” ‬

While admitting thatthe Constitution was silent on quorum of CCT, Justice Onnoghen says by virtue of Section 28 of the Interpretation Act, sitting of CCT with 2 members is valid.

On November 5, 2015, Saraki’s lawyers walked out of the CCT courtroom after the tribunal ruled that the trial must continue despite the pending appeal at the supreme court.

Justice Onnoghne concluded by saying Saraki's appeal lacked merit and is dismmissed. The judgment is unanimously agreed to by the 7-man bench. This means that Saraki's trial at the Code of Conduct Tribunal will continue.

 


Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Oko-Olowo     Abdulrazak Shehu Akorede     Mohammed Kamaludeen     Yekeen Alabi     11th Galadima     IESA     Adeniyi Ojo     Muhammed Abdullahi     Millennium Development Goals     Ayinde Oki     ASKOMP     Kwara Coalition Of Business And Professional Associations     Abdulrasheed Akogun     Alliance For Democracy     Garuba Alikinla Shittu     Adeleke Ogungbe     Abdulwahab Oba     March 18     Ayedun     Kwara North     Lola Olabayo     Ibrahim Issa Jetti     Bayo Mohammed Onimode     HYPPADEC     TIC     Suleiman Abubakar     Riskat Opakunle     Abdulraheem Yusuf     Abdulmajeed Wahab     Biliaminu Aliu     Abdullahi Atanda     Alabi Olayemi Abdulrazak     Kulende-UITH     Government House     Minimum Wage     Yahaya Muhammad     Mashood Dauda     Hassanat Bello     Nnazua     Unilorin     AbdulRazaq Abubakar Jiddah     Akande Idowu Ayoola Muhammed     Samuel Olusegun Adedayo     Abdulrazaq Adebayo     College Of Health     Mashood Abdulrafiu Agboola     Abdulganiyu Oladosu     Kolawole Bashirat     Raliat Islamic Foundation     Belgore     Olatunde Jare     ASMAU PLAZA     Funmi Salau     Women For Change And Development Initiative     Kwara United     Wahab Agbaje     Al-Ilory     Ilorin.Info     Admiralty Villa     Ella Supreme Tissue Paper     Balogin Alanamu     Lai Mohammed     Tescom.kwarastate.gov.ng     Budo Egba     Moshood Mustapha     Umar Yakubu Jaja     Kale Belgore     Jaigbade Alao     Olomu Of Omu-Aran     Oloriegbe     Lateef Ademola Olatunji     Ayo Adeyemi     Umar Bayo Abdulwahab     KW-GIS     Sunday Otokiti     Abdul-Rasheed Na\'Allah     Ibrahim Gambari    

Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

SDP     Adebara     Smart School     Abdullahi AbdulMajeed     Medview Airlines     A.O. Belgore     Okin Group     Onilorin Of Ilorin     Muhammed Aliyu     Elerin Of Adanla     Minister     Onilupeju Of Ilupeju     Ganiyu Abolarin     Ariyo     Rotimi Samuel Olujide     Mufutau Gbadamosi Esuwoye     Funmilayo Zubair     Ahmed \'Lateef     Idowu Aremu     Clement Yomi Adeboye     Agboola Babatunde     Olupako     Razaq Atunwa     Tsaragi     Muhammad Akande Olarewaju Odunade     Abdulmajeed Wahab     Muideen Olaniyi Alalade     Mohammed Khadijat Kubura     Aliyu Muyideen     Economic And Financial Crimes Commission     Doyin Group     Amuda Musbau     Stephen Fasakin     Federal Neuro-Psychiatric Hospital     Guber Aspirant     Ndama Al-hassan     Adaramaja     Ibrahim Taiwo Road     Balogin Alanamu     Seed Technologies     Senate Presidency     Alloy Chukwuemeka     Quareeb Islamic Association     IYA ALFA NLA     NURTW     Kwara Polytechnic     Kunle Okeowo     Sola Saraki Educational Foundation     Special Agro-industrial Processing Zone     Lateef Ademola Olatunji     Voices Of Tomorrow     Oke-Ogun     Aso Ofi     Sunset Workers     Kwara Coalition Of Business And Professional Associations     Joseph Offorjama     Florence Saraki     Babaloja-General     Simeon Sule Ajibola     Muftau Akanbi Oke     Yakubu Dogara     Raji AbdulRasaq     Yekeen Alabi     Babata     Bashiru Makama     Ibikunle Ogunleye     Kwara 2019     Alfa Modibbo Belgore     Universal Basic Education Commission     Shuaib Jawondo     Folashade Omoniyi     Mary Kemi Adeosun     Bolaji Abdullahi     Olokoba Abdullahi Ayinla     Ayodele Shittu     Jaiz Bank     Egbejila